Judge · Одеський окружний адміністративний суд
Токмілова Любов Миколаївна
Register data are shown in Ukrainian, as the state publishes them.
Decisions in 12 months
The number of court documents signed by the judge in the Unified State Register of Court Decisions since November 15, 2025.
Outcomes of decisions
First-instance decisions from January 1, 2024 to November 15, 2026. Compared with all judges of this court and the local courts of Odesa Oblast.
In short
- Most decisions: claims (2,370).
- Where there are enough decisions to compare, the outcomes are close to the other judges of the court.
- The appeal court upheld 83% of the decisions it reviewed on the merits (448).
Your case
Claims
Загальнообов’язкового державного пенсійного страхування, з них
Of 10 similar cases of this judge:
- 5 of 10 — granted
- 4 of 10 — partly granted
- 1 of 10 — denied
Claim granted in full or in part: Judge 95% (94% to 96%) · other judges of the court 94% · Region 94% — higher than the other judges of the court
Claims
Справи, що виникають з відносин публічної служби, зокрема справи щодо
Of 10 similar cases of this judge:
- 3 of 10 — granted
- 6 of 10 — partly granted
- 1 of 10 — denied
Claim granted in full or in part: Judge 86% (82% to 90%) · other judges of the court 87% · Region 87%
Claims
Реалізації податкового контролю
Of 10 similar cases of this judge:
- 7 of 10 — granted
- 2 of 10 — partly granted
- 1 of 10 — denied
Claim granted in full or in part: Judge 88% (80% to 93%) · other judges of the court 94% · Region 94% — lower than the other judges of the court
Claims
Митної справи (крім охорони прав на об’єкти інтелектуальної власності); зовнішньоекономічної діяльності; спеціальних заходів щодо демпінгового та іншого імпорту, у тому числі щодо
Of 10 similar cases of this judge:
- 10 of 10 — granted
Claim granted in full or in part: Judge 95% (88% to 98%) · other judges of the court 98% · Region 98% — lower than the other judges of the court
Claims
Стягнення податкового боргу
Of 10 similar cases of this judge:
- 9 of 10 — granted
- 1 of 10 — partly granted
Claim granted in full or in part: Judge 98% (91% to 100%) · other judges of the court 95% · Region 95%
Claims
Справи щодо примусового виконання судових рішень і рішень інших органів
Of 10 similar cases of this judge:
- 7 of 10 — granted
- 3 of 10 — denied
Claim granted in full or in part: Judge 67% (50% to 80%) · other judges of the court 63% · Region 63%
Claims
Організації господарської діяльності, з них
Of 10 similar cases of this judge:
- 5 of 10 — granted
- 1 of 10 — partly granted
- 4 of 10 — denied
Claim granted in full or in part: Judge 55% (38% to 72%) · other judges of the court 52% · Region 52%
Claims
Військового обліку, мобілізаційної підготовки та мобілізації
Of 10 similar cases of this judge:
- 3 of 10 — granted
- 4 of 10 — partly granted
- 3 of 10 — denied
Claim granted in full or in part: Judge 70% (52% to 84%) · other judges of the court 67% · Region 75%
Claims
Заява про ухвалення додаткового рішення
Of 10 similar cases of this judge:
- 2 of 10 — granted
- 8 of 10 — partly granted
Claim granted in full or in part: Judge 100% (87% to 100%) · other judges of the court 93% · Region 93%
Claims
Адміністрування окремих податків, зборів, платежів, з них
Of 10 similar cases of this judge:
- 4 of 10 — granted
- 2 of 10 — partly granted
- 4 of 10 — denied
Claim granted in full or in part: Judge 57% (33% to 79%) · other judges of the court 73% · Region 73%
Claims
Справи зі спорів з приводу реалізації державної політики у сфері освіти, науки, культури та спорту
Of 10 similar cases of this judge:
- 9 of 10 — granted
- 1 of 10 — partly granted
Claim granted in full or in part: Judge 100% (77% to 100%) · other judges of the court 94% · Region 94%
Claims
Реєстрації актів цивільного стану, крім актів громадянства
Of 10 similar cases of this judge:
- 5 of 10 — granted
- 1 of 10 — partly granted
- 4 of 10 — denied
Claim granted in full or in part: Judge 54% (29% to 77%) · other judges of the court 66% · Region 66%
Claims
Праці, зайнятості населення, у тому числі
Of 10 similar cases of this judge:
- 10 of 10 — granted
Claim granted in full or in part: Judge 100% (74% to 100%) · other judges of the court 93% · Region 93%
Claims
Проходження служби, з них
Of 10 similar cases of this judge:
- 2 of 10 — granted
- 5 of 10 — partly granted
- 3 of 10 — denied
Claim granted in full or in part: Judge 70% (40% to 89%) · other judges of the court 62% · Region 63%
Claims
Біженців
Of 10 similar cases of this judge:
- 2 of 10 — partly granted
- 8 of 10 — denied
Claim granted in full or in part: Judge 20% (4% to 62%) · other judges of the court 34% · Region 41%
Claims
Звільнення з публічної служби, з них
Of 10 similar cases of this judge:
- 2 of 10 — granted
- 8 of 10 — denied
Claim granted in full or in part: Judge 20% (4% to 62%) · other judges of the court 40% · Region 40%
Claims 2,370
withheld in the register: 20
- Granted 51%
- Partly granted 40%
- Denied 9%
- Other 0.3%
Table: judge, court, region
| Outcome | Judge | Court | Region |
|---|---|---|---|
| Granted | 51% 1,210 | 53% | 54% |
| Partly granted | 40% 947 | 35% | 34% |
| Denied | 9% 207 | 10% | 10% |
| Other | 0.3% 6 | — | — |
Among the judges of the court
By case category
-
Загальнообов’язкового державного пенсійного страхування, з них1,585Judge 1,585Court 62,630Region 62,630
Claim granted in full or in part: Judge 95% (94% to 96%) · other judges of the court 94% · Region 94% — higher than the other judges of the court
-
Справи, що виникають з відносин публічної служби, зокрема справи щодо327Judge 327Court 13,842Region 13,842
Claim granted in full or in part: Judge 86% (82% to 90%) · other judges of the court 87% · Region 87%
-
Реалізації податкового контролю93Judge 93Court 4,685Region 4,685
Claim granted in full or in part: Judge 88% (80% to 93%) · other judges of the court 94% · Region 94% — lower than the other judges of the court
-
Митної справи (крім охорони прав на об’єкти інтелектуальної власності); зовнішньоекономічної діяльності; спеціальних заходів щодо демпінгового та іншого імпорту, у тому числі щодо81Judge 81Court 3,122Region 3,164
Claim granted in full or in part: Judge 95% (88% to 98%) · other judges of the court 98% · Region 98% — lower than the other judges of the court
-
Стягнення податкового боргу62Judge 62Court 2,654Region 2,654
Claim granted in full or in part: Judge 98% (91% to 100%) · other judges of the court 95% · Region 95%
-
Справи щодо примусового виконання судових рішень і рішень інших органів33Judge 33Court 2,025Region 2,039
Claim granted in full or in part: Judge 67% (50% to 80%) · other judges of the court 63% · Region 63%
Other categories (10)
-
Організації господарської діяльності, з них29Judge 29Court 1,189Region 1,191
Claim granted in full or in part: Judge 55% (38% to 72%) · other judges of the court 52% · Region 52%
-
Військового обліку, мобілізаційної підготовки та мобілізації27Judge 27Court 2,033Region 3,350
Claim granted in full or in part: Judge 70% (52% to 84%) · other judges of the court 67% · Region 75%
-
Заява про ухвалення додаткового рішення25Judge 25Court 1,683Region 1,772
Claim granted in full or in part: Judge 100% (87% to 100%) · other judges of the court 93% · Region 93%
-
Адміністрування окремих податків, зборів, платежів, з них14Judge 14Court 1,267Region 1,267
Claim granted in full or in part: Judge 57% (33% to 79%) · other judges of the court 73% · Region 73%
-
Справи зі спорів з приводу реалізації державної політики у сфері освіти, науки, культури та спорту13Judge 13Court 332Region 332
Claim granted in full or in part: Judge 100% (77% to 100%) · other judges of the court 94% · Region 94%
-
Реєстрації актів цивільного стану, крім актів громадянства13Judge 13Court 505Region 505
Claim granted in full or in part: Judge 54% (29% to 77%) · other judges of the court 66% · Region 66%
-
Праці, зайнятості населення, у тому числі11Judge 11Court 486Region 488
Claim granted in full or in part: Judge 100% (74% to 100%) · other judges of the court 93% · Region 93%
-
Проходження служби, з них10Judge 10Court 551Region 569
Claim granted in full or in part: Judge 70% (40% to 89%) · other judges of the court 62% · Region 63%
-
Біженців5Judge 5Court 116Region 191
Claim granted in full or in part: Judge 20% (4% to 62%) · other judges of the court 34% · Region 41%
-
Звільнення з публічної служби, з них5Judge 5Court 278Region 278
Claim granted in full or in part: Judge 20% (4% to 62%) · other judges of the court 40% · Region 40%
Appeal 600
Decisions of the appeal court found by the case number. Not every case is appealed, and not every appeal decision can be found.
- Reversed with a new decision 8% 47
- Changed 5% 27
- Upheld 62% 374
- Appeal closed 0.2% 1
- Refused to open proceedings 9% 52
- Appeal returned 17% 99
Dark red is the hardest outcome for the person, lighter is milder, blue is in their favour, grey is no decision on the merits. For claims, the color is from the side of the claimant.
Shares in comparisons are of the decisions with a known outcome; the brackets give the range that holds the share with 95% probability.
These are statistics of past decisions, not a forecast for a particular case. The outcome is found automatically from the operative part of each decision. A decision that fits no outcome is in the row “Other”.
Asset declarations
The annual declarations of the judge from the open register of the National Agency on Corruption Prevention (NACP). Income is for the year, money as of 31 December. The property of family members is part of the judge’s declaration.
Income by year
- 2025 UAH 4.1m
- 2024 UAH 1.8m
- 2023 UAH 2.2m
- 2022 UAH 3.4m
- 2021 UAH 1.3m
- 2020 UAH 1.1m
- Judge
- Family
Declaration for 2025
Real estate
- Квартира · 23.2 m² · Південне judge · since 2010
- Квартира · 40 m² judge · since 2022
- Квартира · 52.8 m² · Одеса family · since 2025
Vehicles
- toyota yaris · 2006judge
- BMW X6 XDRIVE 30D M SPORT · 2025judge
Money
- USDcash 15,000
- UAHin accounts 42,381
All declarations
- For 2025, filed March 29, 2026
- For 2024, filed March 31, 2025
- For 2023, filed March 30, 2024
- For 2022, filed January 30, 2024
- For 2021, filed January 30, 2024
- For 2020, filed March 31, 2021
Source: NACP, public.nazk.gov.ua. Matched by surname, initials, the post of judge and the court. Object types are in Ukrainian. Dollars and euros at the NBU rate of November 19, 2026.
Coming hearings
| Date | Time | Case | Type | Room |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| November 23, 2026 | 14:00 | 420/12780/25 | Administrative | 26 |
| November 24, 2026 | 14:00 | 420/32960/26 | Administrative | 26 |
We do not show the parties and the subject of a case. The schedule of the judge on the court page
Sources: the Unified State Register of Court Decisions, the Judiciary of Ukraine portal. Links to decisions go to reyestr.court.gov.ua.
Work on your cases in Merit
Upload the case file. The system reads the documents, builds an evidence matrix and drafts the procedural documents. You check the result.