Skip to content

Judge · Миколаївський апеляційний суд

Чебанова-Губарєва Наталя Валентинівна

Register data are shown in Ukrainian, as the state publishes them.

Share

Decisions in 12 months

1,783decisions in the register
9%of the decisions of the court in a year
  • Criminal 1,712 96%
  • Administrative offences 71 4%

The number of court documents signed by the judge in the Unified State Register of Court Decisions since November 15, 2025.

Outcomes of decisions

Decisions of the court as an appeal court from January 1, 2024 to November 15, 2026, by the judge-rapporteur. The outcome is what happened to the reviewed decision. Compared with all judges of this court and all appeal courts.

In short

  • Most decisions: criminal cases (2,408), administrative offences (134).
  • In “Рішення слідчого про закриття кримінального провадження” cases, reverses or changes decisions less often than the other judges of the court: 0% against 20%.
  • In “Бездіяльність слідчого, прокурора” cases, reverses or changes decisions less often than the other judges of the court: 0% against 16%.
  • In “Крадіжка” cases, reverses or changes decisions less often than the other judges of the court: 53% against 65%.
  • The Supreme Court upheld 45% of the decisions it reviewed on the merits (38).

Your case

Criminal cases

Administrative offences

Criminal cases 2,408

withheld in the register: 60

Judge 2,408
Court 6,950
Ukraine 173,505
  • Reversed, new decision 7%
  • Reversed and remanded 2%
  • Changed 3%
  • Changed to milder 4%
  • Upheld 70%
  • Proceedings closed 3%
  • Refused to open proceedings 3%
  • Appeal returned 3%
  • Other 6%
Table: judge, court, Ukraine
Outcome Judge Court Ukraine
Reversed, new decision 7% 168 10% 9%
Reversed and remanded 2% 59 4% 5%
Changed 3% 64 3% 5%
Changed to milder 4% 87 4% 4%
Upheld 70% 1,684 65% 58%
Proceedings closed 3% 69 2% 5%
Refused to open proceedings 3% 67 2% 4%
Appeal returned 3% 72 3% 3%
Other 6% 138 — —

Who appealed

Party Judge Court Ukraine
Defence 11% 1,249 16% 18%
Prosecutor 42% 527 54% 55%
Victim 17% 59 33% 44%
Not known 11% 27 11% 23%
Others 9% 346 14% 26%

The share of decisions reversed or changed among the appeals decided on the merits. Each appeal is counted apart.

Among the judges of the court

Decision reversed or changed: ×0.77 of the court average, for the mix of cases. Each dot is a judge of this court.

By case category

  • Тримання особи під вартою505
    Judge 505
    Court 1,427
    Ukraine 24,730

    Decision reversed or changed: Judge 11% (9% to 14%) · other judges of the court 21% · Ukraine 15% — lower than the other judges of the court

    median case length 20 days · withheld in the register: 6

  • Продовження строків тримання під вартою456
    Judge 456
    Court 1,130
    Ukraine 16,102

    Decision reversed or changed: Judge 0% (0% to 1.0%) · other judges of the court 6% · Ukraine 9% — lower than the other judges of the court

    median case length 238 days · withheld in the register: 31

  • Стосовно невнесення відомостей про кримінальне правопорушення до Єдиного реєстру досудових розслідувань239
    Judge 239
    Court 791
    Ukraine 13,045

    Decision reversed or changed: Judge 4% (2% to 7%) · other judges of the court 12% · Ukraine 24% — lower than the other judges of the court

    median case length 21 days · withheld in the register: 1

  • Арешт майна133
    Judge 133
    Court 398
    Ukraine 14,038

    Decision reversed or changed: Judge 22% (16% to 30%) · other judges of the court 24% · Ukraine 31%

    median case length 26 days · withheld in the register: 11

  • Крадіжка Art. 185 CC124
    Judge 124
    Court 335
    Ukraine 8,813

    Decision reversed or changed: Judge 53% (44% to 62%) · other judges of the court 65% · Ukraine 55% — lower than the other judges of the court

    median case length 155 days · withheld in the register: 1

  • Бездіяльність слідчого, прокурора63
    Judge 63
    Court 211
    Ukraine 9,789

    Decision reversed or changed: Judge 0% (0% to 8%) · other judges of the court 16% · Ukraine 16% — lower than the other judges of the court

    median case length 49 days

Other categories (14)
  • Рішення слідчого про закриття кримінального провадження57
    Judge 57
    Court 150
    Ukraine 4,271

    Decision reversed or changed: Judge 0% (0% to 7%) · other judges of the court 20% · Ukraine 34% — lower than the other judges of the court

    median case length 22 days

  • Самовільне залишення військової частини або місця служби Art. 407 CC54
    Judge 54
    Court 140
    Ukraine 1,457

    Decision reversed or changed: Judge 42% (29% to 56%) · other judges of the court 41% · Ukraine 38%

    median case length 195 days

  • Порушення правил безпеки дорожнього руху або експлуатації транспорту особами, які керують транспортними засобами Art. 286 CC47
    Judge 47
    Court 140
    Ukraine 4,094

    Decision reversed or changed: Judge 41% (28% to 56%) · other judges of the court 53% · Ukraine 55%

    median case length 306 days

  • Інші справи та матеріали46
    Judge other — 46 46
    Court 140
    Ukraine 5,518

    Decision reversed or changed: judge — only 0 · other judges of the court 67% · Ukraine 16%

  • Про умовно-дострокове звільнення від відбування покарання42
    Judge 42
    Court 115
    Ukraine 2,034

    Decision reversed or changed: Judge 19% (10% to 33%) · other judges of the court 23% · Ukraine 27%

    median case length 85 days

  • Шахрайство Art. 190 CC33
    Judge 33
    Court 73
    Ukraine 1,878

    Decision reversed or changed: Judge 87% (70% to 95%) · other judges of the court 78% · Ukraine 60%

    median case length 185 days

  • Умисне легке тілесне ушкодження Art. 125 CC32
    Judge 32
    Court 95
    Ukraine 2,345

    Decision reversed or changed: Judge 17% (7% to 37%) · other judges of the court 51% · Ukraine 59% — lower than the other judges of the court

    median case length 194 days

  • Грабіж Art. 186 CC28
    Judge 28
    Court 113
    Ukraine 2,600

    Decision reversed or changed: Judge 54% (35% to 71%) · other judges of the court 54% · Ukraine 40%

    median case length 210 days · withheld in the register: 1

  • Інші скарги28
    Judge 28
    Court 87
    Ukraine 3,743

    Decision reversed or changed: Judge 0% (0% to 16%) · other judges of the court 7% · Ukraine 20%

    median case length 205 days

  • Умисне вбивство Art. 115 CC28
    Judge 28
    Court 91
    Ukraine 4,016

    Decision reversed or changed: Judge 42% (24% to 61%) · other judges of the court 35% · Ukraine 28%

    median case length 328 days

  • Домашній арешт24
    Judge 24
    Court 62
    Ukraine 3,952

    Decision reversed or changed: Judge 21% (9% to 43%) · other judges of the court 20% · Ukraine 22%

    median case length 6 days

  • Про звільнення від покарання і пом’якшення покарання у випадках, передбачених частинами 2 і 3 статті 74 Кримінального кодексу України22
    Judge 22
    Court 82
    Ukraine 281

    Decision reversed or changed: Judge 55% (35% to 73%) · other judges of the court 77% · Ukraine 57%

    median case length 100 days

  • Умисне тяжке тілесне ушкодження Art. 121 CC21
    Judge 21
    Court 77
    Ukraine 2,447

    Decision reversed or changed: Judge 33% (16% to 56%) · other judges of the court 25% · Ukraine 34%

    median case length 278 days

  • Незаконне виробництво, виготовлення, придбання, зберігання, перевезення, пересилання чи збут наркотичних засобів, психотропних речовин або їх аналогів Art. 307 CC20
    Judge 20
    Court 54
    Ukraine 3,827

    Decision reversed or changed: Judge 22% (9% to 45%) · other judges of the court 44% · Ukraine 37%

    median case length 143 days

Administrative offences 134

Judge 134
Court 2,109
Ukraine 79,234
  • Reversed, new decision 21%
  • Changed 4%
  • Upheld 49%
  • Appeal returned 7%
  • Other 18%
Table: judge, court, Ukraine
Outcome Judge Court Ukraine
Reversed, new decision 21% 28 13% 16%
Changed 4% 6 3% 4%
Upheld 49% 66 63% 64%
Appeal returned 7% 10 16% 10%
Other 18% 24 — —

Who appealed

Party Judge Court Ukraine
Defence 36% 91 19% 24%
Victim 17% 6 42% 42%
Others — 3 34% 22%

The share of decisions reversed or changed among the appeals decided on the merits. Each appeal is counted apart.

Among the judges of the court

Decision reversed or changed: ×0.87 of the court average, for the mix of cases. Each dot is a judge of this court.

By case category

  • Вчинення домашнього насильства, насильства за ознакою статі, невиконання термінового заборонного припису або неповідомлення про місце свого тимчасового перебування Art. 173-2 CAO19
    Judge 19
    Court 70
    Ukraine 2,345

    Decision reversed or changed: Judge 25% (10% to 49%) · other judges of the court 33% · Ukraine 46%

    median case length 5 days

  • Порушення вимог фінансового контролю Art. 172-6 CAO16
    Judge 16
    Court 35
    Ukraine 1,016

    Decision reversed or changed: Judge 100% (68% to 100%) · other judges of the court 44% · Ukraine 31% — higher than the other judges of the court

    median case length 24 days

  • Переміщення або дії, спрямовані на переміщення товарів через митний кордон України з приховуванням від митного контролю Art. 483 CusC13
    Judge 13
    Court 63
    Ukraine 2,056

    Decision reversed or changed: Judge 44% (19% to 73%) · other judges of the court 30% · Ukraine 34%

    median case length 20 days

  • Порушення правил торгівлі пивом, алкогольними, слабоалкогольними напоями, тютюновими виробами, електронними сигаретами та рідинами, що використовуються в електронних сигаретах, пристроями для споживання тютюнових виробів без їх згоряння Art. 156 CAO11
    Judge 11
    Court 31
    Ukraine 682

    Decision reversed or changed: Judge 40% (12% to 77%) · other judges of the court 33% · Ukraine 53%

  • Розпивання алкогольних, слабоалкогольних напоїв або вживання наркотичних засобів, психотропних речовин чи їх аналогів Art. 172-20 CAO11
    Judge 11
    Court 36
    Ukraine 1,661

    Decision reversed or changed: Judge 40% (17% to 69%) · other judges of the court 43% · Ukraine 36%

    median case length 1 days

  • Недбале ставлення до військової служби Art. 172-15 CAO10
    Judge 10
    Court 21
    Ukraine 446

    Decision reversed or changed: Judge 0% (0% to 32%) · other judges of the court 57% · Ukraine 52% — lower than the other judges of the court

    median case length 1 days

Other categories (3)
  • Порушення порядку провадження господарської діяльності Art. 164 CAO8
    Judge 8
    Court 26
    Ukraine 669

    Decision reversed or changed: Judge 60% (23% to 88%) · other judges of the court 44% · Ukraine 64%

  • Дрібне хуліганство Art. 173 CAO5
    Judge 5
    Court 32
    Ukraine 960

    Decision reversed or changed: Judge 0% (0% to 43%) · other judges of the court 38% · Ukraine 42%

    median case length 14 days

  • Невиконання батьками або особами, що їх замінюють, обов'язків щодо виховання дітей Art. 184 CAO5
    Judge 5
    Court 17
    Ukraine 631

    Decision reversed or changed: judge — only 4 · other judges of the court 58% · Ukraine 55%

Cassation 113

Decisions of the Supreme Court found by the case number. Not every case is appealed, and not every cassation decision can be found.

Judge 113
Court 1,586
  • Reversed with a new decision 2% 2
  • Reversed and remanded 14% 16
  • Changed 3% 3
  • Upheld 15% 17
  • Appeal closed 4% 4
  • Refused to open proceedings 48% 54
  • Appeal returned 13% 15
  • Other 2% 2

Red: the reviewed decision was reversed or changed; blue: upheld; grey: no decision on the merits.

Shares in comparisons are of the decisions with a known outcome; the brackets give the range that holds the share with 95% probability.

These are statistics of past decisions, not a forecast for a particular case. The outcome is found automatically from the operative part of each decision. A decision that fits no outcome is in the row “Other”.

Asset declarations

The annual declarations of the judge from the open register of the National Agency on Corruption Prevention (NACP). Income is for the year, money as of 31 December. The property of family members is part of the judge’s declaration.

Income by year

  • 2025 UAH 2.5m
  • 2024 UAH 2.3m
  • 2023 UAH 2.8m
  • 2022 UAH 2.2m
  • 2021 UAH 2.3m
  • 2020 UAH 1.6m
  • Judge
  • Family

Declaration for 2025

Real estate

  • Квартира · 57 m² · Миколаїв judge · since 2002
  • Квартира · 77 m² judge · since 2021

Vehicles

None

Money

  • EURin accounts 19,277
  • UAHin accounts 419,204
  • USDcash 64,000

All declarations

Source: NACP, public.nazk.gov.ua. Matched by surname, initials, the post of judge and the court. Object types are in Ukrainian. Dollars and euros at the NBU rate of November 19, 2026.

Coming hearings

Date Time Case Type Room
November 24, 2026 10:00 477/1734/14-к Criminal —
November 24, 2026 10:00 489/8891/25 Criminal —
November 24, 2026 13:00 470/1068/25 Criminal Зал № 3
November 24, 2026 13:00 473/2968/25 Criminal Зал № 3
November 24, 2026 13:00 474/236/21 Criminal —
November 24, 2026 13:00 485/1301/23 Criminal Зал № 3
November 24, 2026 13:00 487/10370/24 Criminal Зал № 3
November 24, 2026 13:00 489/8368/23 Criminal Зал № 3
November 24, 2026 14:00 468/2285/25 Criminal Зал № 3
November 24, 2026 14:00 490/10437/26 Criminal —
November 24, 2026 15:00 487/7911/25 Criminal Зал № 3
November 24, 2026 15:00 490/10459/26 Criminal —
November 24, 2026 15:00 490/5048/24 Criminal Зал № 3
November 26, 2026 09:30 490/4156/26 Criminal —
November 26, 2026 10:00 473/155/25 Criminal Зал № 5
November 26, 2026 10:00 475/874/24 Criminal —
November 26, 2026 13:00 473/2182/17 Criminal Зал № 3
November 26, 2026 13:00 473/2182/17 Criminal —
November 26, 2026 13:00 484/2659/25 Criminal Зал № 3
November 26, 2026 13:00 490/786/21 Criminal Зал № 3
November 26, 2026 13:00 654/1990/15-к Criminal Зал № 3
November 26, 2026 14:00 487/1306/25 Criminal —
November 26, 2026 15:00 488/2309/21 Criminal Зал № 3
December 1, 2026 09:30 484/4412/23 Criminal —
December 1, 2026 10:00 473/515/20 Criminal —
December 1, 2026 10:00 474/310/22 Criminal —
December 1, 2026 10:00 484/6319/25 Criminal —
December 1, 2026 10:00 485/1155/25 Criminal —
December 1, 2026 13:00 473/904/22 Criminal Зал № 3
December 1, 2026 13:00 484/984/26 Criminal Зал № 3

We do not show the parties and the subject of a case. The schedule of the judge on the court page

Recent decisions

Sources: the Unified State Register of Court Decisions, the Judiciary of Ukraine portal. Links to decisions go to reyestr.court.gov.ua.

Merit for lawyers

Work on your cases in Merit

Upload the case file. The system reads the documents, builds an evidence matrix and drafts the procedural documents. You check the result.